Shelter Island House, Shelter Island Heights ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2026

57 photos

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Close to Crescent Beach

Great

8.6

/10

4.9

4.5

Loved by Shelter Island House Hotel guests

Beautiful pool
Cute staff
Fine grounds
Delicious breakfast
Comfortable room
Excellent service

"The pool area is a great gathering place."

aintnoway from United States

read full review

"They do have beach chairs and umbrellas as well as bikes available for you to use which was a nice touch."

Heavenzdesiangel from United States

read full review

"Our room was large, immaculate w/ a spacious walk-in shower."

Judy M from United States

read full review

Rooms with Garden Views

Shelter Island House offers first or second-floor rooms with garden views. Rooms feature bathrobes, a flat-screen TV, and internet. The Double Queen Room, located on the second floor, overlooks the swimming pool and garden. Guests can choose suites with an elegant king-sized bed and a seating area. Some suites feature spa bathrooms with soaking tubs and walk-in showers. A three-bedroom suite includes a king bed in the master bedroom, a queen bedroom, and a bedroom with trundle twin beds.

Dining at The Tavern

The Tavern features a bar and fireplace. Dishes are prepared with ingredients from local farmers and fishermen. Chez Marie, located within Shelter Island House, serves small plates. Guests can enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast and evening drinks by the swimming pool.

Leisure and Activities

Shelter Island House has a swimming pool. Guests can use complimentary bicycles to visit Crescent Beach, which is one block away. The hotel provides beach chairs, umbrellas, and towels. Bocce courts offer entertainment. Guests can visit Whale's Tale for mini golf or the Tuck Shop for ice cream and games.

Location and Transportation

Shelter Island House is one block from Sunset Beach. The hotel is accessible by ferry from Greenport and Sag Harbor. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 85 km away. Go'fors Taxi provides transport to and from the ferry at 631-749-4252. Havens House, which hosts weekend fairs and a local farmer's market, is 2.5 km away.

Hotel Services

Shelter Island House has a gift shop and offers Wi-Fi. The hotel offers amenities for families and groups. The hotel permits dogs under 50 lbs in specified rooms, with prior approval and a non-refundable deposit of $150 per dog.

“Shelter Island House, with its intimate size and lush gardens, provides a tranquil escape one block from the beach. What strikes me most is the blend of historic charm and modern luxuries, creating a warm, personalized experience. With its bicycles for exploring and farm-to-table dining, a stay here feels restorative.”

James DavidEditor-in-Chief at Tohotel

Location: Perfect

9.1/10Review score

View hotel on map

Highlights from guests

Children's AmenitiesKid-Friendly Fun

They offer beach chairs, umbrellas, and bikes for guests to use. My daughter loved it!

Patricia from Canada

Review on

DiningBreakfast Gem

The continental breakfast includes fresh pastries, yogurt, juice, and coffee: a great way to start the day!

Rajesh from India

Review on

Room FeaturesUnique Rooms

Each room is unique with different features. The king-sized room was nicely appointed, clean, and up to date.

Hans from Netherlands

Review on

Spa & LeisurePoolside Paradise

The pool area is great. I loved lounging in one of the many chairs available!

Maria from Spain

Review on

View all

Select your room type

Shelter Island House Hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Suite

2 persons

420 sq. feet

1 King-size bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Queen Room

2 persons

250 sq. feet

1 Double bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Deluxe King Room

2 persons

270 sq. feet

1 King-size bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Double Queen Room

2 persons

455 sq. feet

2 King Size Beds

Shower

Heating

room details

Click button to see more rooms

Show all rooms

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

Shelter Island House Hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Facilities: Very good

7.9/10Review score

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Free parking
Safe deposit box
Pets allowed
Luggage storage

Sports & Fitness

Cycling

Services

Housekeeping

Dining

Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Picnic area/ Tables

Children

Cots
Board games

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Beach access
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Massage
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Sitting area
Garden furniture
Dining table

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Parquet floor

Dining Onsite

Shelter Island House offers a delightful dining experience at the Osprey Bar and Lounge, where American cuisine meets the charm of a cozy bar setting. Guests can enjoy a range of flavors influenced by local farmers and fishermen, complemented by inviting outdoor dining by the swimming pool and a warm ambiance perfect for any occasion.

Osprey Bar and Lounge

American

Ambiance

Cozy interior with dining options near a fireplace or outdoor seating by the swimming pool.

Key Offerings

Dishes crafted with seasonal ingredients from local farmers and fishermen, complemented by a relaxed environment ideal for leisurely meals.

Reservation

Hours vary

Shelter Island House Hotel Location

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Map view

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

City landmarks

Landmark

Dering Harbor Marina

1.0 mi

Event hall

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

1.2 mi

Beach

Crescent Beach

3000 ft

Church

Our Lady of the Isle Church

3700 ft

Landmark

Shelter Island Tennis Club

4200 ft

Landmark

Sylvester Manor

1.1 mi

Amusement Park

Greenport Antique Carousel

2.0 mi

Island

Shelter Island

1.5 mi

Market

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

1.1 mi

Church

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

1.3 mi

Landmark

Railroad Museum of Long Island

1.8 mi

Landmark

Fireboat Firefighter Museum

1.9 mi

Landmark

Manhansett Chapel Museum

1.4 mi

Landmark

Congregation Tifereth Israel

1.9 mi

Landmark

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

1.5 mi

Church

Saint Marys Episcopal Church

1.5 mi

Museum

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation

1.9 mi

Landmark

Camera Obscura

2.0 mi

Gallery

Nova Constellatio Gallery

2.1 mi

Museum

Havens House

1.7 mi

Harbour

Greenport

2.1 mi

Landmark

Fire Fighter Ship New York

1.9 mi

Landmark

Greenport Theatre

2.0 mi

Landmark

Long Island Train Museam

1.9 mi

Landmark

East End Seaport Maritime Museum

2.2 mi

Landmark

Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church

1.9 mi

Landmark

Mashomack Preserve

2.4 mi

Nearby

Shelter Island Country Club

1900 ft

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

1900 ft

Sunset Beach

1900 ft

Restaurants

Eagle Deli

2200 ft

25 W Neck Rd

Explore Shelter Island Heights

Local Experiences

Crescent Beach

11 minutes' walk

Crescent Beach offers stunning views and serene waters, perfect for a relaxing day by the shore or enjoying a sunset.

Dering Harbor Marina

20 minutes' walk

Dering Harbor Marina features beautiful sailboats and a charming atmosphere, ideal for a leisurely stroll along the waterfront.

Shelter Island Tennis Club

15 minutes' walk

This community tennis club offers public courts and friendly matches, welcoming players of all skill levels to join in.

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

25 minutes' walk

Sylvester Manor is a historic site and educational farm offering tours, workshops, and locally sourced produce.

Kayaking at Crescent Beach

11 minutes' walk

Kayaking offers thrilling adventures along the shoreline. Rentals are available nearby, and it's perfect for all experience levels.

Yoga Classes

20 minutes' walk

Relaxing yoga classes are offered at local studios, focusing on mindfulness and balance to rejuvenate your spirit.

Eagle Deli

8 minutes' walk

Eagle Deli serves delicious breakfast and lunch options. Known for sandwiches and fresh ingredients, it's casual and welcoming.

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

20 minutes' walk

This farm-to-table restaurant features local cuisine in a historic setting. Reservations recommended for an exquisite dining experience.

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

25 minutes' walk

An engaging venue with live music and local entertainment. Check the schedule for family-friendly events and performances.

Greenport Antique Carousel

10 minutes' drive

A charming historic carousel offering fun rides for all ages, with beautifully restored horses that are a delight for children.

Getting around

City Centre

Shelter Island Heights16 min · 4300 ft

Airports

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)127 min · 52.3 mi

Republic Airport (FRG)169 min · 70.0 mi

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 15:00-22:00

Check-out

from 07:00-11:00

Guest Parking

Private parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

Wireless internet is available in public areas for free.

Children & extra beds

Maximum capacity of extra beds in a room is 1.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Number of rooms:

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Shelter Island House Hotel from previous guests about their experience.

Review score

Based on 16 verified reviews

9.7/10

Perfect

100%

Recommend

Cleanliness

8.3/10

Comfort

8.7/10

Facilities

7.9/10

Location

9.1/10

Staff

8.7/10

Value for money

7.8/10

Pros

Breakfast quality

Comfortable beds

Friendly staff

Pool area

Harbor views

Cons

Small rooms

High prices

Limited parking

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

Questions of the users

About Shelter Island House

What is the best way to reach the nearest beach from Shelter Island House?

2 November 2023

The closest beach, Crescent Beach, is just a short 5-minute walk from the hotel.

Are there dining options available during my stay, particularly for meals?

5 December 2023

Currently, the restaurant is closed for the season, but the outdoor bar operates Wednesday through Sunday from 2 PM to 8 PM. Additionally, there are several nearby restaurants open for dining.

Can guests access different floors for accommodations?

7 January 2024

Deluxe King Rooms are available on both the first and second floors; however, specific room assignments cannot be guaranteed.

Are there transportation services available to the nearby beach?

15 January 2024

While a taxi service operates on Shelter Island, Crescent Beach is conveniently located within a 5-minute walking distance from the hotel.

Where exactly is Shelter Island located?

20 January 2024

Shelter Island is situated on Long Island, New York, offering a picturesque setting close to Crescent Beach.

Does Shelter Island House cater to pet owners?

22 January 2024

Yes, the hotel is pet-friendly, welcoming dogs under 50 lbs with prior approval. There is a $150 non-refundable deposit for each dog, with a limit of two dogs per room.

What amenities are available for guests looking to unwind during their stay?

3 February 2024

Guests can enjoy complimentary Wi-Fi, access to the outdoor swimming pool, beach chairs, umbrellas, towels, and bicycles for exploring the beautiful island.

Are there any special arrangements for events or weddings at Shelter Island House?

12 February 2024

The hotel offers an event venue, The Boathouse, located just 3.2 kilometers away, making it an ideal location for weddings or corporate retreats.

What local attractions and activities are recommended for visitors?

18 February 2024

Guests can explore local beaches, engage in water sports, visit farms, or enjoy fine dining and boutique shopping, among other activities available on the island.

Is public transportation an option for accessing Shelter Island?

22 February 2024

Traveling to Shelter Island commonly involves taking the Hampton Jitney to Greenport and then an 8-minute ferry ride. Taxi services are also accessible on the island.