Open Hearth Lodge, Sister Bay ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

75 photos

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States, 54234

Near the beach

Perfect

9.4

9.8

/10

4.6

4.9

Loved by guests

Dog-friendly amenities
Cute staff
Clean rooms
Perfect location

"Brand new dog-friendly rooms! They even provide a bed, blanket, ball, and treats for your dog."

Erika

read full review

"The property is so cute! The hope tub was hot, the pool was cold, the fire pits outside were sooo cute!"

Cheyenne from United States

read full review

"There is an onsite fenced dog park AND walkable trails."

Alison from United States

read full review

Location

Open Hearth Lodge is open year-round for guests to explore Door County's natural beauty. The hotel is situated close to great restaurants and entertainment options in Sister Bay, providing easy access to local attractions. Guests can enjoy picturesque views and relaxing outdoor spaces amidst nature's surroundings.

Rooms

The hotel offers 42 rooms, accommodating both couples and larger groups in an intimate setting. Each room is designed to offer comforts akin to home, creating a welcoming environment after a day of exploration. Guests will find a variety of room arrangements to meet their needs.

Amenities

Open Hearth Lodge provides a range of amenities aimed at enhancing guest experiences. The property features a cozy atmosphere with an open fire, inviting guests to unwind. Outdoor spaces allow for relaxation and connection with the beautiful surroundings.

Entertainment

The Lodge is located within a short distance of various entertainment options available throughout Door County. Guests can engage in activities that include local dining and events tailored to seasonal offerings. This allows for a diverse array of experiences that showcase the charm of the community.

Group Accommodations

Open Hearth Lodge caters to both families and large groups with its room capacity. This makes it a suitable choice for family reunions, gatherings, or group retreats focused on quality time. The hotel's intimate atmosphere complements shared moments with friends and family.

Highlights

Location: Door County's natural beauty

Rooms: 42 rooms

Amenities: open fire

Entertainment: great restaurants

“What strikes me is the exceptional pet-friendly focus, from the off-leash area to dedicated washing stations, a rare find executed with clear care. I'm impressed by reports of spotless, odor-free rooms, even in pet-designated areas, showing a commitment to cleanliness. It seems that beyond value, the property delivers full kitchens and thoughtful touches like fireplaces, ensuring a comfortable, well-equipped stay.”

James DavidEditor-in-Chief at Tohotel

View hotel on map

Highlights from guests

Children's AmenitiesFamily Fun!

Kids loved the playground and open spaces. We enjoyed playing cornhole. Plenty of games kept everyone entertained all day.

Kevin from Canada

Review on

Guest ParkingEasy Access

Finding the hotel was easy, right off the main road! Parking was plentiful and convenient to the entrances.

Mei from China

Review on

Spa & LeisureRelax and Recharge

The indoor pool and hot tub were very clean and warm! Relaxing by the outdoor fire pits was also great.

Carlos from Spain

Review on

Room FeaturesSuites Surprise

Our spacious king suite had a full kitchen and jetted tub! The bed was comfortable, too. We'll be back!

Ingrid from Sweden

Review on

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Room

2 persons

26 m²

1 King-size bed

Shower

Sauna

room details

Queen Room Two Queen Beds

2 persons

26 m²

2 King Size Beds

Shower

Sauna

room details

Deluxe King Room

2 persons

30 m²

1 King-size bed and 1 Sofa bed

Shower

Sauna

room details

One-Bedroom Apartment

2 persons

46 m²

1 King-size bed and 1 Sofa bed

Shower

Sauna

room details

Click button to see more rooms

Show all rooms

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
24-hour security
Luggage storage
Lift
Vending machines
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key card access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness centre
Canoeing
Skiing
Hiking
Cycling
Bowling
Golf course
Fishing

Guest Parking

Dryer
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Services

Pet amenities available
Housekeeping
Laundry
Welcome drink

Dining

Outdoor dining area
Picnic area/ Tables

Business

Fax/Photocopying

Children

Cots
Board games
Children's play area
Toys

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled
Bathroom for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Indoor swimming pool
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
BBQ facilities
Leisure/ TV room
Sauna
Jacuzzi

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Dining table
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Washing machine
Free toiletries
Sink

Self-catering

Dryer
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Parquet floor

Location

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States, 54234

Map view

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States, 54234

City landmarks

Gallery

Frykman Studio Gallery

1.2 km

Landmark

Corner of the Past Museum

2.0 km

Landmark

Fine Line Designs Gallery

2.2 km

Gallery

George Burr Gallery

2.2 km

Golf Course

Bay Ridge Golf Course

850 m

Landmark

Sister Bay Historical

990 m

Golf Course

Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf

1.0 km

Marina

Sister Bay Marina

2.3 km

Landmark

Family Artist

1.4 km

Landmark

Sister Bay Athletic Club

1.5 km

Gallery

Francis Hardy Gallery

3.1 km

Park

Sister Bay Beach

2.0 km

Park

Sister Bay Dog Park & Community Garden

2.7 km

Landmark

Waterfront Park

2.0 km

Museum

Ephraim Historical Foundation

3.0 km

Gallery

Lardiere Gallery and Studio

3.2 km

Landmark

Sister Bay Sports Complex

2.8 km

Gallery

K. Allen Gallery

2.9 km

Landmark

Ephraim Preserve at Anderson Pond

3.0 km

Gallery

Anderson's Dock

3.1 km

Museum

Anderson Store Museum

3.1 km

Landmark

Anderson Store and Dock

3.1 km

Landmark

Red Putter Mini Golf

3.4 km

Landmark

Pioneer Schoolhouse

3.4 km

Landmark

Pioneer School

3.4 km

Landmark

Water Street Gallery

3.9 km

Landmark

Pioneer Cabin

3.4 km

Church

Ephraim Moravian Church

3.5 km

Landmark

Bethany Lutheran Church

3.5 km

Landmark

Historic Iverson House

3.6 km

Nearby

Golf Course

Bay Ridge Golf Course

170 m

Restaurants

SubExpress

1.5 km

2579 S Bay Shore Dr

Explore Sister Bay

Local Highlights

Sister Bay Marina

25 minutes walking

Sister Bay Marina offers scenic waterfront views and opportunities for boating and fishing, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.

Frykman Studio Gallery

15 minutes walking

Frykman Studio Gallery showcases local artworks and provides insight into the creative process, making it a unique cultural stop.

Corner of the Past Museum

5 minutes driving

Corner of the Past Museum features historical artifacts and exhibits, offering a glimpse into the region's rich heritage.

Sister Bay Historical

15 minutes walking

Sister Bay Historical presents charming exhibits on local history, perfect for anyone interested in the area's past.

Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf

15 minutes walking

Pirate's Cove offers exciting mini-golf with themed courses, an enjoyable activity for families and groups looking for fun.

Bay Ridge Golf Course

10 minutes walking

Bay Ridge Golf Course provides a challenge for golf enthusiasts and beautiful views, perfect for a relaxing day outdoors.

Sister Bay Beach

25 minutes walking

Sister Bay Beach is a lovely spot for sunbathing and swimming, making it ideal for families seeking a day of relaxation.

SubExpress

18 minutes walking

SubExpress serves fresh subs in a casual setting, popular for its quick service and customizable options.

Family Artist

15 minutes walking

Family Artist offers a cozy atmosphere and hearty meals. Specializes in family-friendly options with local ingredients.

Sister Bay Athletic Club

20 minutes walking

Sister Bay Athletic Club hosts fitness classes and activities, perfect for staying active or relaxing after a busy day.

Waterfront Park

25 minutes walking

Waterfront Park features scenic views and picnic areas, often hosting community events that are enjoyable for all ages.

Getting around

City Centre

Sister Bay24 min · 2.0 km

Airports

Delta County Airport (ESC)440 min · 293.1 km

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 15:00-22:00

Check-out

until 11 am

Guest Parking

Private parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

is available in for free.

Breakfast

The hotel Open Hearth Lodge provides visitors with a free full breakfast.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Number of rooms:

Questions of the users

About Open Hearth Lodge

Is a continental breakfast part of the room rate?

14 November 2024

Yes, a continental breakfast is included in the price of the room.

What is the nightly fee for bringing a dog?

22 December 2024

The fee for having a dog in the room is $15 per night.

Do all rooms come equipped with a refrigerator?

10 January 2025

Yes, every room includes at least a small fridge, along with a microwave and a coffee maker. Only suites have full kitchens.

Are there specific rooms available for guests traveling with pets?

05 February 2025

Dog-friendly rooms are available in all room types, with no size restrictions, though it's recommended to keep the number of dogs to a maximum of three in a single room.

Can a Blu-ray player be rented during my stay?

15 March 2025

Yes, a Blu-ray player can be rented for $3.00 per night or $5 for the duration of your stay.

Are there pools and hot tubs available for guests?

28 April 2025

Yes, both the indoor pool and hot tub are open for use.

Is there adequate space for parking a truck and trailer?

20 June 2025

Yes, the Open Hearth Lodge features elongated parking spots, with additional grassy areas available for larger vehicles like trailers.

Do the rooms feature a microwave for guest use?

03 August 2025

Suites and deluxe rooms include a microwave, while lodge rooms have access to a microwave in the breakfast area at any time.

Is there an elevator for accessing the second floor?

17 September 2024

Yes, there is an elevator available for convenience.

Can you explain the cancellation policy and deposit requirements?

11 October 2025

A deposit covering the first night plus tax is required. If cancelled more than two weeks in advance, a refund minus a $15 transaction fee is provided. Cancellations within two weeks but more than two days in advance will result in a gift certificate for a future stay.